Google Ads usually brings better leads for services people actively search for, because it reaches them at the moment they're looking. Facebook and Instagram ads are better at creating demand, reaching people who aren't searching yet but would buy if they saw the right offer. Which one brings better leads depends on what you sell and how people shop for it.

Many businesses end up using both. Here's how we decide between them when setting up Facebook and Instagram ads or search campaigns.

What's the core difference?

Google Ads reaches searchers. Someone types "emergency plumber Santa Rosa," and your ad shows up. Facebook and Instagram reach scrollers. Someone is looking at photos from a friend's trip, and your ad appears because they fit the audience you chose. Searchers are further along in deciding. Scrollers are earlier, but there are far more of them.

Which businesses do better on Google Ads?

  • Urgent services like plumbing, roofing repair, towing and emergency dental care
  • Services people already know they need, like HVAC tune-ups or legal help after an accident
  • B2B services that buyers research, such as accounting or IT support

If people search for it by name, search ads are usually the better first bet. Our post on whether Google Ads is worth it covers that in more depth.

Which businesses do better on Facebook and Instagram?

  • Visual services and products: remodels, landscaping, med spas, restaurants, retail
  • Things people don't search for until they see them, like a new fitness class or a home upgrade they hadn't considered
  • Local events, openings and limited-time offers
  • Businesses with a strong before-and-after story

Why do Facebook leads sometimes feel worse?

Because the person wasn't looking for you a minute ago. Instant lead forms make it easy to submit a name and number without thinking much, so some leads don't remember filling out the form. That doesn't make the channel bad. It means the follow-up has to be fast and the form needs a little friction, like a qualifying question, to filter out casual clicks.

How do I keep lead quality up on Facebook and Instagram?

  • Add 1 or 2 qualifying questions to the form, such as town or timeline
  • Call or text within minutes, not hours
  • Test sending traffic to a landing page instead of an instant form
  • Use real photos and videos of your work, not stock images
  • Set up Meta's Conversions API so the platform learns which leads became customers

How should I compare the 2 channels?

Compare cost per booked job, not cost per lead. Facebook leads are often cheaper, and Google leads often close at a higher rate. The only fair comparison follows each lead through to the sale. That means tracking every lead's source and marking which ones turned into customers.

Can they work together?

Yes, and this is often where the best results come from. Facebook and Instagram ads build familiarity, so when those people later search, they recognize your name and click. Retargeting ads on Meta can also bring back people who visited your site from a Google ad but didn't call.

When isn't Facebook the right move?

If you sell an urgent service and your budget only covers 1 channel, start with search. Also be careful in regulated areas like credit, housing, employment and some health services, where Meta restricts targeting options. Those restrictions can make it harder to reach the right audience.

Frequently asked questions

Should I use instant forms or a landing page?

Instant forms usually bring more leads at a lower cost. Landing pages usually bring fewer leads who are more serious. Test both and judge by booked jobs.

Do Instagram and Facebook ads need separate campaigns?

Not usually. Both run through Meta's ad system, and you can show the same campaign across both. Separate them only if one placement clearly performs better.

What kind of creative works best for local businesses?

Real photos and short phone videos of your team, your work and your customers usually beat polished stock images. People can tell the difference, and authentic content earns more trust.

Which should I start with?

If you're unsure, a free marketing review will look at how people search for your services and recommend a starting channel.